The Final Score

 

By Debbie B

DLB1248@aol.com

 

 

 

Ben stepped to the door and opened the heavy wooden structure wide, staring out into the yard.  From across the room, Adam and Hoss stood in front of the massive stone fireplace watching their father.  Guest milled around the great room, swapping pleasantries with one another as they waited the arrival of the honoree.  The small band that had set up in front of the gun case had stopped playing over half an hour ago and had now helped themselves to the punch.

 

Ben closed the door, a scowl deepening the fine lines that creased his brow.  His eyes caught those of his oldest son’s and held their gaze for several moments.  Adam could see that the anger that had been present not more than an hour ago had vanished and had been replaced with worry.  Adam watched as his father’s eyes swept the room as if they were expecting to see the boy for whom the celebration was being given.  When they failed to locate the subject, the dark chocolate eyes found Adam’s once again and then the blue eyes of his middle son.

 

Adam nudged Hoss and motioned silently for the big man to follow him.  Together, the two brothers walked casually across the room and joined their father on the opposite side.

 

“Do you want us to saddle up and go look for him?” Adam asked softly.

 

Ben stared, wide-eyed into his son’s face and shook his head.  “Let’s give him just a few more minutes, surely he’ll be here by then.  I can’t imagine what has held him up, after all, he knew this party was for him.  How many times does a man turn twenty-one?” whispered Ben, going to the door for what seemed like to the brothers, the hundredth time that evening.

 

“He sure ‘nough has been actin’ strange the last few days.  Reckon that has anythin’ to do with his being late for his own party?” Hoss questioned as he peeked over his father’s shoulder into the darkness outside.

 

Ben turned with a surprised expression on his face as he looked at Hoss.  “I’m not sure son, it did seem as if Joseph had something on his mind, but he never said anything to me about it and I didn’t think to question him.  Did he happen to say anything to either of you?”

 

Adam and Hoss both shook their heads no.  “I know he was excited about this here party.  It’s all he talked about yesterday when we were roundin’ up those steers,” offered Hoss.  Adam nodded his head in support of his brother’s statement.

 

Ben smiled at a guest as they walked by and then turned his attention back to his sons.  “I’m getting worried about him, I know he said there was something important that he had to take care of, but he promised to be home in plenty of time to get ready for the party,” muttered Ben.

 

A soft rapping on the front door caused all three Cartwrights to glance at one another.  “Probably another guest,” whispered Ben as he reached for the handle, ready to welcome whomever it might be.

 

Ben smiled when he spied his best friend, Roy Coffee, standing in the doorway.  Roy,” greeted Ben, “Come on in, we were beginning to wonder if you were going to make it or not.”

 

Roy took off his hat and returned the smile.  “Wouldn’t have missed it for anythin’ in the world Ben.  Where is that youngest cub of yours?” laughed the Sheriff as he scanned the room full of guest with his eyes.

 

“He’s not here yet,” Adam explained.

 

Roy looked confused and then turned his attention to Ben.  “That sure don’t sound like Little Joe.”

 

“No, and I’m getting a little worried about him.  You didn’t happen to see him in town this evening, did you?” Ben questioned.

 

Roy scratched his head and was just about to answer when a second knock at the door interrupted him.

 

“I’ll get it,” Adam volunteered and then grabbed the door.

 

“Clem,” Adam smiled.

 

Clem removed his hat and greeted his friend.  “Sorry to bother you, but I need to speak with Roy.”

 

“Sure, come on in, Roy,” called Adam and then nodded his head in Clem’s direction.

 

Clem greeted the other Cartwrights and then pulled Roy off to one side, handing him a slip of paper.  “I thought you might need to see this,” he said.

 

Roy glanced around at the men who stood close by and then scanned the message that his deputy had handed to him.  “Ben, I think you should see this,” Roy said and then handed the paper to Ben.

 

Ben looked from one to the another and then read the note.  Adam watched as the color drained from Ben’s face, leaving his father with a white, ghost like appearance.

 

“What is it Pa?” asked Adam taking the message from his father’s trembling hands and reading it aloud.

 

TERRITORIAL PRISON

ROY COFFEE, SHERIFF

VIRGINIAG CITY, NEVADA

 

To inform you of the release of one, Lucas Tatum…Stop

And one, Timothy Chase…Stop

Wednesday, of this week…Stop

 

Adam folded the paper in half and glanced again at his father.  “What do you think this means?”

 

“I wish I knew,” Ben said, the worry evident in the tone of his voice.  “Wednesday, that gives those two plenty of time to get to Virginia City.”  He cast anxious eyes at his two sons and then turned to Roy.  “You haven’t noticed any strangers around town have you?”

 

Roy shook his head back and forth.  “I’d a known, Ben, if they were in town.  Clem and I’ll keep a sharp eye out for them and if we see’em, you’ll be the first to know.  Personally, I doubt that they will cause any trouble.  My bet is that those two hooligans have learned their lesson.”

 

“I still don’t like it,” Ben muttered and then was forced into a conversation with some of his guest.

 

Hoss poked Adam in the ribs and slipped out, unnoticed.  Adam glanced over his shoulder to be sure they were not seen and then followed Hoss outside and into the moonlight.

 

“I think we better go look for the kid, Adam.  My gut tells me that somethin’s wrong,” Hoss said in a soft voice.  “Joe wouldn’t miss his own birthday party, not unless somethin’ happened to him.”

 

“I agree, but what?  I’m like Roy, I don’t think that Lucas and Timothy pose a threat to Joe, after all, it’s been better than five years,” Adam explained.  “But just the same, let’s saddle up and have a look around.  Did Joe happen to tell you where he had to go that was so important?”

 

Hoss followed Adam into the barn, “Nope, not a word.  I did notice that he crammed somethin’ into his saddlebag though, as he was mountin’ up.”

 

“Well, that won’t help us any.  Let’s start in town and see if anyone there has seen him this afternoon or perhaps earlier this evening,” suggested Adam as he mounted his horse.

 

 

The bearded man shoved the young handsome man into the cell.  The chains that were attached to the man’s wrist and ankles clattered noisily as he stumbled forward, nearly falling to his knees.  The bearded man jabbed his thick wooden walking cane into the chained man’s back.

 

“Step it up a mite,” he growled in a menacing tone.

 

The young man cast his eyes over his shoulders at the man behind him and silently cursed the dirty bearded man.

 

“Put the collar on’em,” he ordered his companion, pointing to the thick iron neck collar that hung on a ring, which had been hammered into the thick rock wall.

 

The young man’s deep-set hazel eyes widened in fear when the other man grasped the iron collar and started toward him.  Joe Cartwright stepped backward, trying to avoid the hands that attempted to affix the slave-ware around his neck.

 

“You can’t put that thing on me,” shouted Joe, as he stumbled backward.  The shackles around his ankles made it impossible for him to move with any speed at all.

 

“On your knees, Cartwright,” the bearded man barked out his order.

 

Joe refused to lower himself and stood rock still.  The sudden movement of the bearded man caught Joe off guard as the thick cane walloped him across the backs of his legs, just in the bend behind the knees and knocked Joe to the ground.  Joe groaned loudly as he fought to get up, but with his wrists chained so closely to his waist, it was impossible to do so.

 

The second man dropped to the ground next to Joe and though Joe fought with all that he could, soon the iron collar had been locked into place.

 

“Help him on his feet,” snapped the bearded man.

 

Joe was hauled unceremoniously to his feet and forced to face the bearded man.  “Stand still,” growled his attendant.

 

Joe stopped struggling; figuring that to fight now was useless.  “Who are you and what do you want with me?” Joe demanded.

 

The man thumped his cane on the solid rock floor and paced back and forth in front of the youngest Cartwright.  “You disappoint me Joe.  You don’t even remember me, do you?”

 

Joe studied his jailer’s face for several moments.  It was hard to tell just what the man looked like; the beard was so thick on his face that the man’s features were hidden behind the bristles of his beard.  The man’s eyes were sky blue, but held a mixture of hate and doom in their depths.  His captor walked with a limp, carried a thick wooden cane and tapped it along as he continued to pace back and forth in front of his prisoner.  The man’s voice sounded somewhat familiar to him, but still, Joe could not recall having ever known the man before.

 

Lucas scowled at Joe and stopped in front of the younger man.  “Put the chain on the collar and take up the slack,” he ordered the other man.

 

Timmy grabbed the chain that was attached to a long steel spike hammered deeply into the thick rock wall.  On the collar was a round ring that the chain was slipped through and then locked onto the short length of chain that separated Joe’s wrist.  Joe watched in horror, frightened of being chained and caged like an animal, but refusing to let these depraved men see how frightened he really was.

 

The second man ran the length of chain through two more rings affixed into the rock wall and then pulled through a narrow opening that had been chiseled into the rock.  On the other side of where a heavy iron door had been installed, a thick iron lock, making the chain adjustable from the outside of Joe’s iron and rock prison cell locked the chain into place.  Joe’s wrists were pulled upward and held into place next to the ring on the collar, making a very uncomfortable position for the frightened boy to be in, and rendering him virtually helpless to anything that the pair of jailers wanted to do to him.

 

Joe’s breathing was rapid, his chest burned with the effort and he felt his heart pounding hard, deep within his chest cavity.  “Are you going to tell me who you are and why you are doing this to me?” he tried to mask the fear in his voice and hoped that the pair would not be able to see the way in which his body trembled.

 

“Did ya hear that, Tim, Cartwright still ain’t figured out who we are!” laughed Lucas. 

 

Lucas leaned his face within inches of Joe’s.  Joe’s body had been forced against the cold rock wall by the shortening of his chain.  He could do nothing to move his head and free his face from the offending breath of the man who was, but inches from him.

 

The man tapped his cane on the floor several times, the sound unnerving the prisoner and echoing in the hollow room.  “The name’s, Tatum, Lucas Tatum,” snarled Lucas.  He tipped his head at his friend, “that’s Tim Chase,” Lucas sneered and then tossed back his head and laughed at the haunted look that crossed Joe’s young face as the color suddenly drained from the frightened features. 

 

Raw fear filled the hazel eyes that threatened to fill with tears as Joe stared into the face of his former classmate.  Joe could not believe his eyes, for the years had changed the other boy, now a young man of twenty-three.  Lucas looked at least ten years older than he actually was, the beard was coated with gray, a scar just above the man’s right eye traveled downward across the right cheek of Lucas’ face, gave Lucas a grotesque expression to his once handsome features.  No wonder Joe hadn’t been able to recognize the man.

 

“I thought you said once, that you were not afraid of me…but guess that was a lie, cause I can see the fear in your eyes right now.  In fact, I can smell the fear seeping from every pore in your body,” taunted Lucas.  “And it’s justified, Cartwright.  You will soon fear me more than the devil himself.  I promised ya, I’d get even with ya, and ya know I keep my promises, don’t ya?”

 

Joe swallowed the knot that had suddenly grown in his throat and tried to turn his eyes away from the piercing blue eyes that scrutinized him.  The action fueled the other man’s hatred.

 

“When I was in prison, we were forced to look eye to eye to our guards, I expect you to do the same thing, Cartwright.  Ya got five years to learn who is boss around here, and that’s me.  Now look at me!” Lucas demanded.

 

Joe gritted his teeth and refused to turn his eyes to face Lucas.  Lucas only laughed and then Joe felt the stabbing pain to his middle as Lucas jabbed the end of his cane deeply into Joe’s stomach.  Joe’s knees buckled beneath him but the thick iron collar made it impossible for him to fall or bend over, giving in to the pain.  Tears stung his eyes, but he refused to let them to roll free as he squeezed his eyes tightly and clenched his teeth against the agony of the assault.

 

“Look at me when I speak to ya,” Lucas ordered a second time.

 

This time, Joe turned his eyes so that he was looking directly into the eyes of his tormentor.  “Five years, Cartwright, that’s what it’s gonna cost ya, just like it cost us,” sneered Lucas.

 

“Scares ya too, don’t it?  I know what ya thinkin’, that your family will find ya and save ya ass…but it won’t work this time, cause no one, not even God, knows where we’re at,” laughed Lucas.  “I’m gonna make ya pay Little Joe, just like I promised ya I would.  Ya gonna die in this here cage, with them chains around ya neck and it’s gonna be slow and painful.  I plan on makin’ ya suffer, just like Tim and I did.”

 

Lucas backed up a step or two and turned his back to the chained man.  “See this here leg?  They broke my leg Cartwright, hurt like hell, too.  They never even let me see the doctor to have it set…made me a cripple…”

 

Lucas began thumping his cane on the floor.  His eyes seemed to glaze over and Joe could feel the hatred emitting from the man’s trembling body.

 

Joe shivered as he watched the transformation take over Lucas’ body.  Joe jumped when Lucas screamed out in frustration and twirled back around to face him.  “I’m gonna do the same to you, Joe Cartwright.  I’m gonna make ya a cripple, just like me, but ya ain’t gonna know when it’ll happen.  It’s gonna be a surprise!”

 

“What do ya make of them promises, Cartwright?  Ya shakin’ real bad.  Lookit here Tim, the high and might Joe Cartwright’s afeared of me!”  Lucas’ wicked laughter filled the room and Joe turned his head away to keep from watching the evil expressions on the man’s face.

 

“Say it Cartwright…let’s hear ya say…I’m afeared of Lucas Tatum,” the man demanded.

 

When Joe refused to acknowledge the statement, Lucas began thumping his heavy cane.  Joe chanced a glance at the depraved man and could hardly believe his eyes.  The blue eyes had turned red and Joe suddenly felt as if he were in hell, standing before the devil himself.

 

Without warning, Lucas’ hand lashed out and struck Joe hard against his cheek.  Joe’s head snapped backward, hitting the hard rock behind him.  He tasted the blood in his mouth where his teeth had bitten into the tender flesh inside his mouth.  Joe swallowed several times and glared at Lucas with hate burning in his eyes.

 

“Answer me when I ask you a question,” yelled Lucas, the thumping of his cane getting louder as his anger grew.

 

“Go to hell,” muttered Joe through clenched teeth.

 

His statement only served to anger Lucas more and using his opened hand, Lucas left his mark on the face of his captive.  Joe was powerless to defend himself against the attack as Lucas rained his fury against the tender flesh of Joe’s face.

 

When Lucas had finished, Joe’s face was marred by the handprint that left their brand on the fiery flesh of Joe’s cheeks.  Tiny droplets of blood trickled from the corner of his mouth. Lucas grabbed a handful of Joe’s dark curls and yanked his head upward.

 

“Tsk, tsk, tsk,” whispered Lucas.  “Such a bad boy…but you’ll learn.  Just stand there for a day or two, and you’ll soon learn to be a good boy, Cartwright.”  Lucas released the dark curls, allowing Joe’s head to drop as far as the wide iron collar would permit.

 

Lucas motioned for Tim to follow him and together, they left the cell.  The thick iron door was pulled shut and a large iron lock sealed shut the door.  The light was extinguished, and the pair strolled away to the outside of the cave that was now home to the youngest Cartwright.

 

Joe waited until he was sure that his tormentors were gone before he opened his eyes.  The room was dark, not a sliver of light could be found and it took Joe’s eyes several minutes before they became accustomed enough to be able to see through the darkness.  Joe felt his body shiver as the cold, solid rock pressed into his back.  He needed to sit down, but the collar with the chain pulled tightly would not permit him to do so.  His arms ached from having been pulled upward, close to his neck and made stationary.  His ankles burned where the shackles had rubbed against the flesh of his legs, leaving a burning sensation about his ankles.

 

Suddenly, Joe’s hazel eyes filled with tears.  It was his birthday, his twenty-first birthday to be exact, and here he was, locked away in a make shift cell someplace where only God knew the location.  Though he tried to stop them, the tears rolled slowly down his burning cheeks.  At home, Joe knew that his father and brothers were waiting for him.  They had planned a big celebration in his honor, a birthday party to celebrate his special day.  His family had planned for weeks just for this night, and now, without a doubt, Joe would miss the celebration.  Joe wondered if his family had begun to search for him, knowing in his heart that before they realized that he was missing, his father would flume for several hours about his being late to his own party.

 

“I’m sorry, Pa,” whispered Joe to the darkness as he struggled against the chains that held him in their cold grasp.  Eventually, Joe tired of his battle and leaned his weary body against the rigid walls of his rock prison.

 

 

“Sorry, Adam, but I ain’t seen Little Joe since…hmm…night before last.  Wednesday, I think it was.  He came by here on his way home.  He seemed a little put out about somethin’, don’t know what though.  I didn’t ask him, he just ordered a beer and then left without so much as a thank ya,” Bruno explained to the pair of Cartwright brothers.

 

“Want another, beer?” he asked and then poured one when Hoss nodded his head yes.

 

“Got any ideay where he could’ve gone, Adam?” Hoss pondered out loud.  He downed his beer and when he placed the mug on the counter, it clanged slightly.

 

Adam had his back to the bar, watching the crowded room for any of his younger brother’s friends.  Adam shook his head.  “Nope. I wonder where everyone is tonight?” Adam said, more to himself than to his brother.

 

Hoss glanced over at Adam and shrugged his shoulders.  “Probably out at the Ponderosa waiting for Little Joe.  Come on Adam, we might as well head on back, Joe for sure ain’t in here.  Maybe he’s already home.”

 

Hoss pushed his tall hat down on his head and jerked his pants back up to his waist, for they tended to slide downward at times.  Adam snickered, amused at his brother’s gestures and followed the bigger man from the barroom. 

 

As Adam unwrapped his mount’s reins from the hitching post, he sighed deeply.  “If Joe’s not got a very good reason for worrying Pa, he sure is going to be in a lot of trouble.”

 

Hoss, who had already mounted up, turned Chubb around so that he could face his brother.  “I sure ‘nough don’t wanna be around when Pa starts his shoutin’.  Man, last time he got started, he rattled the winders in the entire house,” laughed Hoss.

 

“I don’t know, Hoss.  I’m getting worried about that baby brother of ours.  Something’s not right, we should have heard from him by now,” Adam mused aloud.

 

“Yeah, well, you know Joe…most times he forgets where he’s suppose to be and when he’s suppose to be there.  If’n he’s found a pretty little gal somewhere, he’s most likely havin’ himself a private little party,” laughed Hoss.

 

“Joe?  You can’t be serious Hoss, Joe might think he’s a lady’s man, but in truth, I doubt seriously if he’d know what to do with a real woman,” joked Adam.  “You saw the way he nearly panicked the other night when Belle down at the Bucket of Blood tried to lure him upstairs with her!”

 

Hoss couldn’t help but laugh out loud too.  “Aw Adam, Belle’s gotta be at least forty years old!  I’d a panicked too if’n she’d tried to drag me up them stairs with her!”

 

Adam snickered and shook his head and then just as quickly turned serious.  “Hoss, Belle isn’t as old as you think, and she’s not as bad as people make her out to be.  She’s a nice lady, and not too bad looking either, when she washes all that paint off her face.”

 

Hoss stared in shock at his older brother.  “And just how would you know?  When have ya seen her without her…paint?” quizzed Hoss as he studied his brother’s expressions.

 

Adam just turned his dark eyes toward his brother and smiled.  “Now Hoss, I wouldn’t be a gentleman if I were to tell all of the lady’s secrets, now would I?”

 

Hoss pulled back on the reins and grabbed Adam by the arm, forcing his brother to stop as well.  “Ya been up to her room, ain’t ya big brother?”  Hoss smiled shyly, the gap between his front teeth clearly seen in the glow of the street lantern.  “Tell me Adam, is she as good as the men say she is?” he whispered as he cut his eyes around to be sure that no one else heard him ask the question.

 

Adam couldn’t help but to laugh at the expression on Hoss’ rotund face.  “Better,” whispered Adam and then nudged Sport into a canter.

 

 

By the time that Adam and Hoss had returned to the ranch, Ben had sent his guest home.  Hop Sing was standing in a chair taking down the Chinese lanterns that he had hung earlier in the day.  He was angry; it was plain to see by the dark fire that burned in his eyes.  Neither brother had to ask why or at whom the little Chinaman’s anger was directed, they both knew.  Hop Sing continued to work and mutter in his own strange language as Adam and Hoss proceeded to the house.

 

Ben was standing in front of the fireplace, jabbing at the dying embers with the poker.  At the sound of the door opening, he turned and glared at his two sons.

 

“Just where in blazes have the two of you been?  Don’t you realize that you left me here, alone mind you, with a whole roomful of people demanding to know where Joe was and then when they realized that the two of you were missing as well, they all began shouting at me?” ranted Ben.

 

“Answer my question!” he snapped, leaving no margin of doubt to his sons that he was very angry and worried.

 

“We went into town to see if we could find Joe,” explained Adam.

 

Ben seemed to calm, “Well?  Did you find him?”

 

“Nosir,” Hoss replied.  “Ain’t no one seen hide nor hair of him.”

 

Ben brushed his hand across the front of this face and then looked again at his sons.  “He’s got to be somewhere…we just have to figure out where.”

 

 

It had been too many hours since Lucas and Timmy had left their prisoner alone in his dark cell.  The hunger pains gnawed at his insides, making his stomach growl and the pounding pain in his head nearly blinded him.  Joe’s mouth was dried out and he longed for a drink of cool water.  His legs had grown weak from supporting his body and his knees had folded slightly, adding to the pressure of the iron collar around his neck that now supported the majority of his weight.

 

The iron door squeaked as it was pulled opened.  The lantern, held high over Timmy’s head, shed its bright light into the darkened cell and caused Joe to have to squint his eyes to keep from being blinded by the brilliant glow.  Lucas and Timmy entered the room and stood silently, observing their captive for several moments before either of them spoke.

 

“Wa…ter,” Joe forced the word up from the back of his throat as he strained to see the faces of the ones who held him chained against the rock wall.

 

“What was that?” asked Lucas, an evil smile spreading across his face.  “Water?  Is that what ya said?”

 

“Plea…se” stammered Joe.

 

“Did ya hear that, Tim?  Cartwright’s all ready learnin’ some manners.  Think we gotta give him a drink?” taunted Lucas as he jabbed the end of his cane into Joe’s already aching stomach.

 

Timmy just smiled but said nothing; he was watching the hazel eyes that were trying to focus on his face.  Something in the way that they stared at him unnerved him.  “Yeah, why not?” he answered at long last.

 

Lucas jerked his head around and looked at his helper.  “Naw, not just yet.  Little Joe has to tell me something first, don’t ya Joe,” Lucas said as he returned his attention to the young man who was practically dangling by his neck chain.

 

“Can ya say, ‘I’m afeared of ya, Lucas’…can ya say that Cartwright?  Just once, and I’ll let ya have a drink of this nice cold water.”  Lucas pulled the cork from the canteen he was holding and gently tipped the spout upward and watched Joe’s eyes widen as the precious water trickled onto the hard rock floor.

 

“Just say those words…and the canteen’s all yours,” smirked Lucas as he replaced the cork.

 

Joe licked his lips, the water looked too good to be true.  Joe felt the scabs that had formed on his chapped lips and longed for a taste of the canteen’s contents.  Lucas laughed and jabbed his cane at Joe a second time.

 

“Come on Cartwright, it ain’t gonna kill ya to admit it,” laughed Lucas.  “Either say it, or I pour the water out on the ground,” Lucas tempted.

 

Joe watched Lucas’ expression and felt the hate growing in his heart.  “I should…have killed you…when I had the…chance,” cursed Joe, his voice dry and cracked as he forced his thoughts into words.

 

Lucas’ laughter faded and he glared at Joe.  He yanked on the cork and turned the canteen upright, allowing the water to spill onto the floor.  His eyes never left Joe’s face and when he saw the beginnings of tears forming in his former classmate’s eyes, he began laughing hysterically.  He stepped up to within inches of Joe’s face.  Joe could feel the man’s spittle as he spoke.

 

“Ya ain’t so high and mighty now are ya, Little Joe?”

 

“Bastard,” whispered Joe, which earned him several punches to his face.

 

The blood spewed from his nose as Lucas repeatedly hammered away at Joe.  When the furious man tired of Joe’s face, he turned his wrath to Joe’s stomach where he delivered several jabs with his fist.  Joe tried to twist his body away from the assault but in so doing, one hard punch hit him in his lower back, knocking the wind from his lungs.  Joe screamed in agony and then succumbed to the pain as he lost contact with the world around him.

 

 

“We’ve covered nearly every inch of this ranch, Pa, and still haven’t found a trace of him,” Adam said as he tipped his canteen upward and allowed the cool water to empty into his mouth.  When he had satisfied his thirst, he punched the cork back into the spout and laced the strap around his saddle horn.  He then lifted his hat from his head and swiped his sleeve across this brow to wipe away the droplets of sweat.

 

Ben sat staring off into the distance and slowly circled, with his eyes, the surrounding area.  Hoss and Adam could see the intense fear that had taken residence in their father’s eyes and knew that Ben was grieving for his youngest son.  It had been three days since Joe’s birthday party that he had failed to attend; three days of worry, searching and praying.  It was as if the boy had dropped off the face of the earth, for there was no sign of Joe, no word from anyone in regards to his whereabouts.  What were they to think?  Had Joe met with an accident in some remote section of the ranch where he might have lain, hurt, or wounded, until death had claimed him?  Ben had even thought that perhaps his youngest son might have been kidnapped, but that was ruled out after the second day when no word had been sent to them asking for a cash settlement. 

 

“Pa?” Adam said gently.  “Pa?” he repeated when his father failed to acknowledge him. 

 

“I’m sorry Adam, I guess my mind was somewhere else,” Ben said softly, the sadness in his voice and in his expression visible for all to see.  “I was thinking about…your…brother.”

 

“Pa, why don’t we call it a day, it’s getting late.  Maybe we’ll have better luck tomorrow,” suggested Adam. 

 

Ben was worn out and Adam knew that he needed rest, but doubted seriously that his father would call off his search for the missing boy for more than an hour or two.

 

“All right son.  We best be getting back to the ranch.  Maybe Hoss had found something,” Ben agreed as he turned his horse back toward the house.  “It’s nearly supper time anyway, we can eat and rest up a bit and then look a while longer, at least until nightfall.”

 

Adam refrained from answering his father’s statement and instead turned his horse around and followed his father back to the ranch.

 

It was with great surprise that met the anxious father’s eyes when he rode into the yard to find his youngest son’s pinto standing at the hitching rail. 

“Adam!” Ben nearly shouted as he jumped down from his mount and rushed to the pinto’s side.

 

Just then the door to his home opened and Hoss hurried to join his father.  His look was grave as he greeted his family.  “It ain’t what’cha think Pa,” Hoss started to explain but stopped, seeing the glimmer of hope reflecting back at him from the pair of chocolate eyes.

 

“It’ not?” Ben said in a whispered voice.

 

Hoss pinched his lips tightly together and shook his head.  “Nosir, his horse came in about half and hour ago…alone.  I’m sorry Pa,” Hoss forced out his words.   “I know what ya were thinkin’.”

 

Ben, who had been standing with his hands on Joe’s horse, drew in a deep breath and let it out slowly.  For a moment he was speechless.

 

“Did you check him over real good?” he asked Hoss at last.

 

“Yessir, he was clean, no sign of anythin’,” answered Hoss.

 

Adam came around to join his father and brother and unlaced the flap to Joe’s saddlebag.  “Did you check in here?  You said something the other day about seeing him stuff something into them?”

 

“Lordy, Adam, I plum forgot,” Hoss stated, his voice sounding his excitement.

 

Both Ben and Hoss waited as Adam rummaged through the contents.  “Nothing,” he told them, “except this wadded up paper,” sighed Adam as he unruffled the paper.

 

“Dadburnit,” groaned Hoss, “I was ahopin’ we’d find somethin’ that might help us.”

 

Ben placed his hand on Hoss’ shoulder in a gesture of comfort and turned toward the house.  “Come on boys, we’ll all feel better after we eat.”

 

“Pa, wait a minute,” called Adam, studying the paper.  “Take a look at this, wonder what it means?” he said as he handed the paper to his father.

 

Ben glanced at Adam and then Hoss, took the paper from his son and scanned the scribbled words on the paper.

 

‘See ya soon, Cartwright.’

 

Ben looked again into the faces of his sons, puzzlement written all over his own face.  “I have no idea,” he stammered.

 

Adam pulled a second scrape of paper from his brother’s saddlebag and unfolded it.

  “Look, this one says, ‘Watch ya back, Cartwright’.”  Adam handed the second paper to his father and waited until Ben had read the short message for himself.

 

“This sounds like some sort of threat or warning, are there any more?” Ben asked and then waited until Adam checked the other side of the saddlebag.

 

“One more, but that’s all,” Adam said and began to undo the tiny ball of paper before handing it to his father.

 

‘I got a surprise for ya birthday.  Can’t wait to give it to ya’.

 

Hoss, who had been looking over his father’s shoulder, scratched his head.  “Reckon it’s from some gal?” he suggested.

 

“No,” Adam answered quickly.

 

“What makes ya so sure?” Hoss wanted to know.

 

“Because Hoss, no lady would call Joe, Cartwright, and this second note does sound like a threat, just like Pa said,” Adam explained.  “Besides, look at the handwriting, most ladies aren’t this sloppy, this is definitely a man’s writing.  What do you think, Pa?”

 

“I agree, but whose?  And more importantly, why?” Ben said, scanning the faces of each son. 

 

 

Joe had no idea how long he had been unconscious, only that it was dark again in the cell and cold.  He shivered and was surprised to find that he could move his arms more freely.  He was more surprised when he realized that his chain attached to his collar had been loosened and now he could move around a bit.  Joe tried to stand, but found that next to impossible in his weakened condition and the fact that his ankles were still shackled together.

 

“Damn,” he cursed silently as he managed to pull himself up, into a sitting position and began rubbing the backs of his legs where the muscles had tightened.

 

Joe took a deep breath to ward off the nausea that had suddenly overtaken him.  The unexpected pain that seized the pit of his stomach caused him to moan loudly.  He was passed hungry, he was starving, and his stomach had gone hours and hours, possibly days with no food or water.  Joe had no concept of time; he had no idea if it were day or night outside.  The only things that he was sure of, was the fact that he was hungry, thirsty, cold and scared. 

 

Surely, he thought, Lucas and Timmy were not going to let him starve to death, though that did seem to be the jest of things.  Joe wiped the dampness from his face and tugged at the chain that remained attached to his collar. 

 

“Pa,” he heard himself muttering as he closed his eyes against his rising fear.  “Please hurry, ya gotta find me,” he whispered, fighting the urge to give in to his dismay. 

 

Joe heard the clicking sound of Lucas’ cane and cringed.  The sound had begun to get on his nerves, and he knew that with the arrival of the man, who carried the menacing stick, he was in for more misery.  Joe pulled himself to his feet, clinging tightly to the chain for support, staggered slightly and waited for the heavy door to be pulled opened.

 

“Well, lookit here,” sneered Lucas as Timmy held the lantern up, “Cartwright’s on his feet, finally.”

 

Lucas moved further into the room, and watched Joe as he leaned against the wall.  “Ya hungry, Joe?  It’s been better’n three days, almost four really.  Guess the old stomach’s getting pretty hollow by now, reckon so Tim?”

 

Lucas jabbed his cane out at Joe, but Joe managed to step aside and avoid the jab.  “Why are you…doing this?” Joe muttered, almost too weak to even speak.  “I’ve never done anything to you…except for what you deserved.”

 

“Oh yeah?  Is that what ya think, Cartwright?  Well, ya wrong.  Ya know all my life I’ve had to listen while someone was always comparin’ me to ya.  ‘Why can’t ya be more like Little Joe Cartwright, how’s come ya ain’t smart, like Joe Cartwright?  Ya ain’t as nice lookin’ as that handsome Joe Cartwright’, well guess what Cartwright?  I got tired of hearin’ it, especially from my old man,” growled Lucas.

 

He swung out his cane and caught Joe on the shoulder.  The stricken boy winced with the pain, and grabbed his shoulder.  “That’s not my fault, Tatum,” Joe said in defense of himself.

 

“Oh no?  Well, that’s your opinion.  I’ve hated ya since we were kids, since that first day I saw ya old man bring ya to school on that big fine horse of his’n.  I hated ya more the day that Lizzie Carlton kissed ya under that old oak tree.  I was sweet on her myself, but you?  You never cared on whit about her and ya made her cry more’n once, I hated ya for that, cause she’d never paid me no mind, she didn’t know I existed when ya was around.  She only had eyes for ya…”

 

“Lucas…I was only ten years old!  Surely you can’t hate me for those reasons?” stammered Joe shocked at the man’s confessions of why he hated him.

 

“There’s more Cartwright, plenty, like when ya got that pinto of yours for ya birthday.  I’d been begging my pa for a horse for over a year and he said ‘get a job, then ya buy what ya want’.  And then, just because ya pa’s rich, all ya gotta do is ask’em for somethin’ and he gets it fur ya.  It ain’t fair, it just ain’t fair.  That’s why I hate ya Joe, them’s my reasons.”  Lucas pounded his cane on the rock floor, his eyes had gotten bigger and he seemed to be staring a hole right through his captive.

 

“Lucas…listen, just name your price and let me go.  My pa will give ya anything ya want, just set me free.”  Joe hated himself for begging, but he had to get out of there, anyway that he could.

 

Joe realized too late that he had said the wrong thing.  Lucas turned dark, angry eyes on him and stepped forward, his cane raised high in the air.  Joe turned his back and pressed his front side against the hard stone.

 

  “YOU THINK MONEY IS ALL I WANT?” he shouted as he brought the stick down across the back of his victim.

 

Joe’s head snapped back as the pain coursed along his spine.  Again, Lucas raised the hard stick and walloped Joe, nearly knocking the wounded boy to his knees. Again and again, Lucas brought his cane down on Joe’s back until Joe gave up trying to protect himself as he fell face down on the ground.

 

Lucas raised the stick one last time and was about to deliver one last blow when his friend’s voice stopped him.

 

“Lucas, wait…don’t hit him again, he’s…he’s already out cold,” Timmy reached out his hand and grasped Lucas’ arm.  “I’ve got a better idea,” he smiled.

 

Lucas slowly lowered his arm, “What?” he asked, seeing the gleam in his partner’s eyes.

 

“Hmm…hmm…” stammered Timmy.

 

 He hadn’t really had a plan, he was just afraid that Lucas would end up killing the other boy.  Joe was already in bad shape, what with having been deprived of food and water for three days, and then there were the wounds from where Lucas had continually beaten the boy.

 

“Well?” shouted Lucas, growing impatient with Timmy.

 

“Why don’t we…”

 

Lucas smiled  suddenly, “break his legs?”

 

“Umm…I…I…don’t know, ya think that’s a good idea?  I mean, he’s already near dead, I thought ya wanted to keep’m here for five years?  If’n he gets any sicker, he’ll die too soon.”  Timmy was stalling for time, trying to think of a plan that would keep him and Lucas from going back to jail for murder.

 

Lucas seemed to be considering Timmy’s words.  At last he spoke, “I don’t care when Cartwright dies, now, next week, five years from now, I don’t give a damn.  I just wanna watch him suffer.”  Lucas began pacing back and forth, clicking the end of the cane on the rocks as he moved about.

 

He stopped suddenly and faced Timmy.  “Tell ya what we’ll do, go get that bucket of slop and the dish water and bring it in here.  MOVE!” he bellowed when Timmy hesitated.

 

Timmy jumped into action and hurried to do, as Lucas had demanded.  He reached for the slop bucket, glancing down into the pail at the contents.  He almost retched, the leftovers had started to mold, and he had to shoo away the flies that buzzed about.  He picked up the dishpan, the water was murky and there remain tiny residues of food floating around on the top.  Reluctantly, he carried both back to the cell where Lucas waited and set the pail and the dishpan down on the ground.  Joe had started to regain consciousness and had pulled himself into a sitting position.

 

Lucas glanced down at the slop and snickered.  “Here’s ya supper, Cartwright,” he said.  “And something to drink.  Enjoy it, if ya don’t eat all of it, I’m gonna break ya leg, and if ya don’t eat it after that, I’m gonna break ya arm, and I’ll keep on breakin’ ya bones, til it’s all gone!”

 

Lucas smiled at Timmy, picked up the lantern and started for the door.  When he stopped and turned back around, his eyes were filled with loathing and Joe swore that they had red sparks shooting out at him. 

 

“Ya got two hours Cartwright, ya understand, just two hours, and if it ain’t gone, well…I dun told ya what I’d do to ya.  Oh, and don’t get no ideay about pouring any of it out, cause if’n ya do, well…ya won’t like what I’ll do to ya then.”

 

He was gone, the thick iron door clanged shut and Joe was alone again.  He sat for several minutes, giving himself time to clear his head and hopefully to think straight.  After five or ten minutes, he inched his way along the cold hard rock until he found the bucket of slop and the dishpan.

 

It was hard to make out in the dark, what had been tossed into the pail.  Joe cringed when he dipped his fingers into the contents and felt the greasy, slime that floated on the top layer.  It was all that he could do to keep from vomiting as he scooped up, with his fingers, a morsel from the bottom of the bucket.  He carefully lifted it to his nose and sniffed.  The odor was repulsive and Joe slung the morsel off his fingers.  There was no way he could eat that stuff, no matter that he was starving, he hadn’t gotten so hungry that he could be forced into eating what he considered, pig’s slob.

 

His other hand found the dishpan and Joe slowly allowed his fingers to dip into the soapy water.  It was disgusting as well, but Joe knew that even without food, the body had to have liquids, so he raised the dishpan to his lips, took a deep breath and tipped the water to his lips.  He gagged as the first drops entered his mouth and after several swallows he had to put aside the pan.  When he began coughing, he gagged and the disgusting liquid came back up into his mouth.  Joe clenched his mouth together tightly and forced himself to swallow the mixture.  Once it went down and stayed down, Joe took a second drink and then a third.

 

His mind begged him to give up, to let Lucas Tatum do what he had to do, kill him if need be.  But his heart urged him to fight, fight for his life, fight to get back to his father, his brothers, his home.  Joe felt the tears as they filled his eyes and when the rolled freely down his face, he didn’t even bother to wipe them away.  He felt less than a man did, less than a dog chained and caged like an animal and he wondered if anyone even cared enough to find him.

 

 

 

Roy, someone sent these messages to Little Joe…all we gotta do is ask around town and find out who!” shouted Ben as he slammed his fist down on the sheriff’s desk in front of Roy.

 

“Ben, I understand your frustrations, but how in blazes are we gonna know for sure who wrote those notes?  And second, do ya really think that the person who did would own up to it if we were lucky enough to find the person?” Roy shouted back, just as loudly.

 

Ben straightened up and sighed.  “I suppose not, but someone gave him these notes, they just didn’t drop out of the air!”

 

Roy stood to his feet and walked around his desk and sat down on the corner.  “I know that, Ben.  But ya ever stop to think that just maybe, someone put them in his saddlebags…when he wasn’t lookin’?”

 

“Pa…” Adam jumped to his feet as well, “Roy might have something there.  Suppose Joe was in…say the saloon…Bruno said he was there last Wednesday, what if someone did slip them inside the bag?”

 

Ben scratched his head and plopped down in a chair.  “Say they did, one maybe, but three?  No, I think the notes were delivered at three different times.”

 

“So, that means, say once while Joe was in the saloon on Wednesday.  Joe came back into town on Thursday and went to the blacksmith’s shop, remember Pa, ya sent him to pick up that harness Jonesy was fixin’ for ya.  Let’s see, on Friday morning, the day of his party, Hop Sing sent him back into town to the bakery to pick up more of that special cake flour that he likes to use.  That would account for the three days and the three notes,” smiled Hoss.

 

Ben, Adam and Roy stood speechless in awe of Ben’s soft-spoken son.  Ben started laughing, “Hoss, you never say much, but when you do, you say it all!”  Ben moved to Hoss’ side and slapped him gently on the back.  Hoss blushed red and then stuffed his fingertips into the pockets of his trousers.

 

“All we have to do now, is find someone else who was in town on those days that might have seen something,” Adam said.

 

“Adam, there were people all over the place, how do you reckon to single out just one?” questioned Roy.

 

“Maybe there weren’t just one, what if there were three different people what put those notes in Joe’s saddlebags?” volunteered Hoss.

 

“Okay,” Roy said, “So now we gotta find, not just one person, but three.  How do you reckon on doin’ that?”

 

All four men exchanged looks with the others, looks of doubts filling their eyes as they glanced around the room.

 

“Well, it was a thought,” muttered Hoss, discouraged and down hearted.  “I think I’ll go over to the saloon and get a beer.  Anyone wanna go along?  Adam?”

 

“No thanks, I think I’ll mosey over to the livery and have a talk with Jonesy.  What about you, Pa?” Adam asked.

 

Ben stood to his feet; the days of worry had taken its toll on him.  He looked tired and worn, his son had been missing for nearly a week now with no signs, and hope of ever finding the boy had begun to fade. 

 

“I think I’ll go to the bakery, maybe Marge noticed something,” he said as he put his hat on his head and followed his sons outside.  “Thanks, Roy,” he called over his shoulder.

 

 

 

Joe had backed himself up as far as his chain would allow him, into the darkest corner of his cell.  The tapping of the wooden cane against the stone floor had alerted him to the arrival of Lucas Tatum.  Joe cringed, for he had no doubt that the crazed man and his partner would keep his promise.  He had been unable to eat the slob, he had vomited up the soapy dishwater and those two things would earn him a broken leg.

 

Joe heard the turning of the key in the lock and watched as the heavy iron door was eased opened.  Lucas’ features were hidden in the darkness of the cell by the lantern light behind him that Timmy held high over their heads.

 

Joe gulped, his hands trembled but he placed them behind his back, so that Lucas would not see how they shook.  Joe watched as Lucas ordered Timmy to hold the lantern so that he could look into the slop bucket.  Joe saw the man’s eyes swiftly turn and look at him, they were dark and filled with anger and hate.

 

“You didn’t eat your supper,” Lucas stated in an angry tone.

 

Timmy had his free hand held behind his back.  Joe could not make out what it was that the man carried but knew that whatever it was, it would not be something that he wanted or needed.

 

“Take up the slack on his collar,” ordered Lucas.

 

Timmy turned, the object in his hand still hid from Joe’s view as Timmy slipped into the side room and began yanking on the chain.  Joe immediately felt himself being pulled along and as he slid along the cold floor, he struggled to his feet.  By the time that the chain had been shortened as much as possible, Joe’s back was pressed against the wall.  He heard the chain being locked in place to prevent him from moving away.

 

Timmy returned and looked to Lucas for further instructions.  “Put the shackles on his wrists, this time, chain them behind his back.”

 

Timmy hesitated briefly while looking at the fear that flooded the hazel eyes of the young man chained to the wall.

 

“Don’t move Cartwright, I’d just as soon shoot ya, as break ya leg,” warned Lucas as he pointed his pistol at Joe.  “Now, put ya hands behind ya back.”

 

Timmy had the shackles in his hand and moved next to Joe. 

 

“You’re nuts, Lucas, loco,” stammered Joe, who was finding it harder and harder to breath.

 

“SHUT UP!” screamed Lucas as he whacked Joe with his cane.  “Put ya hands behind ya,” he bellowed and raised the cane high in the air.  “Ya wanna feel this on ya head?”

 

Joe swallowed and turned his eyes on Timmy as he put his hands behind his back.  Joe felt the cold iron as it wrapped around his wrist.

 

“He’s crazy, Timmy, surely ya realize that?” whispered Joe.

 

Timmy paused and glanced over his shoulder at Lucas.  The man was mad, driven by hate, the man had tuned into a lunatic.

 

“Help me get outta here Timmy, and I promise, I’ll help you stay outta prison,” Joe said softly.

 

Timmy seemed to be considering Joe’s proposition until Lucas’ loud voice broke through his thoughts.

 

“Hurry it up, you idiot!” he screamed at Timmy.

 

Timmy clamped the last shackle onto Joe’s wrist and then backed up, averting his eyes so that he could not look into the frightened eyes of Lucas’ captive.

 

Lucas advanced on Joe who was determined that Lucas would not see the fear that he knew was in his eyes.

 

“Say it Joe, tell me how frightened you are?” whispered Lucas, his voice soft and smooth.  “Say it, just once.”

 

Joe swallowed the fear he felt building in his throat that made him want t